Sweet Nostalgia

87 results
  • 87 results

Twisted Petite Hoops - At Present Twisted Petite Hoops - At Present
Best SellerMade to Order

Twisted Petite Hoops

 Ariel Gordon Jewelry
From $148
Heart Helium Studs - At Present Heart Helium Studs - At Present
Made to Order

Heart Helium Studs

 Ariel Gordon Jewelry
From $213
Mini Helium Initial Studs - At Present Mini Helium Initial Studs - At Present
Made to Order

Mini Helium Initial Studs

 Ariel Gordon Jewelry
From $150
Heart Helium Hoops - At Present Heart Helium Hoops - At Present
Best SellerMade to Order

Heart Helium Hoops

 Ariel Gordon Jewelry
$775
5 Diamond Butterfly Necklace - At Present 5 Diamond Butterfly Necklace - At Present
Final Sale

5 Diamond Butterfly Necklace

 EF Collection
$775 $1,095
Save $320
Gold Plated Heart Ring - At Present Gold Plated Heart Ring - At Present
Ready to Ship

Gold Plated Heart Ring

 Annika Inez
$170
Neon Rainbow Gemstone Necklace - At Present Neon Rainbow Gemstone Necklace - At Present
Best SellerMade to Order

Neon Rainbow Gemstone Necklace

 Encirkled Jewelry
From $1,350
Gold Plated Voluptuous Heart Earrings, Small - At Present Gold Plated Voluptuous Heart Earrings, Small - At Present
Ready to Ship

Gold Plated Voluptuous Heart Earrings, Small

 Annika Inez
$225
Gold Plated Heart Necklace Large - At Present Gold Plated Heart Necklace Large - At Present
Ready to Ship

Gold Plated Heart Necklace Large

 Annika Inez
$265
Gold Plated Heart Necklace, Small - At Present Leya Kaufman wearing Annika Inez jewelry and Lionheart pendant
Sold out

Gold Plated Heart Necklace, Small

 Annika Inez
Beam Ear Cuff - At Present Beam Ear Cuff - At Present
Made to Order

Beam Ear Cuff

 CLED
From $160
Beam Ring - At Present Beam Ring - At Present
Made to Order

Beam Ring

 CLED
From $185
Beam Necklace - At Present Beam Necklace - At Present
Made to Order

Beam Necklace

 CLED
From $170
Diamond & Rainbow Chloe Bar Necklace - At Present
Final Sale

Diamond & Rainbow Chloe Bar Necklace

 EF Collection
$521 $695
Save $174
Voluptuous Heart Earrings, Small - At Present Voluptuous Heart Earrings, Small - At Present
Ready to Ship

Voluptuous Heart Earrings, Small

 Annika Inez
$195
Voluptuous Heart Earrings, Large - At Present Voluptuous Heart Earrings, Large - At Present
Ready to Ship

Voluptuous Heart Earrings, Large

 Annika Inez
$325
Bigger Heart Ring - At Present Bigger Heart Ring - At Present
Ready to Ship

Bigger Heart Ring, Silver

 Annika Inez
$185
Heart Ring - At Present Heart Ring - At Present
Best SellerReady to Ship

Heart Ring

 Annika Inez
$145
In The Loop Necklace - At Present In The Loop Necklace - At Present
Made to Order

In The Loop Necklace

 CLED
From $105
ITL Trio Earrings | Earth - At Present ITL Trio Earrings | Earth - At Present
Made to Order

ITL Trio Earrings | Earth

 CLED
$340
In The Loop Hoops, Small - At Present In The Loop Hoops, Small - At Present
Made to Order

In The Loop Hoops, Small

 CLED
From $140
Avens Stud Earrings - At Present Avens Stud Earrings - At Present
Made to Order

Avens Stud Earrings

 CLED
From $120
Avens Earrings - At Present Avens Earrings - At Present
Made to Order

Avens Earrings

 CLED
From $170
Love Earrings with Large Heart Drop - At Present Love Earrings with Large Heart Drop - At Present
Made to Order

Love Earrings with Large Heart Drop

 CLED
From $150
Avens Signet Ring - At Present Avens Signet Ring - At Present
Made to Order

Avens Signet Ring

 CLED
$135
Heart Signet Ring - At Present Heart Signet Ring - At Present
Made to Order

Heart Signet Ring

 CLED
$135
Moon Signet Ring - At Present Moon Signet Ring - At Present
Made to Order

Moon Signet Ring

 CLED
$135
Heavy Metal Heart Earrings - At Present Heavy Metal Heart Earrings - At Present
Made to Order

Heavy Metal Heart Earrings

 NOTTE
$118
Jumbo Farfalla Glow Pearl Necklace - At Present Jumbo Farfalla Glow Pearl Necklace - At Present
Made to Order

Jumbo Farfalla Glow Pearl Necklace

 NOTTE
$228
Lucky Me Necklace - At Present Lucky Me Necklace - At Present
Made to Order

Lucky Me Necklace

 NOTTE
$138
Lullaby Pearl Necklace - At Present Lullaby Pearl Necklace - At Present
Made to Order

Lullaby Pearl Necklace

 NOTTE
$168
Palermo Pearly Necklace - At Present Palermo Pearly Necklace - At Present
Made to Order

Palermo Pearly Necklace

 NOTTE
$138
Grand Cravat Earrings - At Present Grand Cravat Earrings - At Present
Final Sale

Grand Cravat Earrings

 Annika Inez
$475 $545
Save $70
Grand Cravat Earrings, Large - At Present Grand Cravat Earrings, Large - At Present
Ready to Ship

Grand Cravat Earrings, Large

 Annika Inez
$295
Magical Mixy Gemstone Necklace - At Present Magical Mixy Gemstone Necklace
Best SellerMade to Order

Magical Mixy Gemstone Necklace

 Encirkled Jewelry
From $1,295
Small Magical Mixy Gemstone Necklace - At Present Small Magical Mixy Gemstone Necklace - At Present
Best SellerMade to Order

Small Magical Mixy Gemstone Necklace

 Encirkled Jewelry
From $995
Candy Opal Gemstone Necklace - At Present Candy Opal Gemstone Necklace
Best SellerMade to Order

Candy Opal Gemstone Necklace

 Encirkled Jewelry
From $750
Peach Pearl Cashmere Rainbow Gemstone Necklace - At Present Peach Pearl Cashmere Rainbow Gemstone Necklace - At Present
Best SellerMade to Order

Peach Pearl Cashmere Rainbow Gemstone Necklace

 Encirkled Jewelry
From $1,295
Spring Fling Gemstone Necklace - At Present Spring Fling Gemstone Necklace - At Present
ExclusiveMade to Order

Spring Fling Gemstone Necklace

 Encirkled Jewelry
From $1,295

Curate Your Collection

Be the first to explore our AP Edits and stylist exclusives.

Choose Quality

We promise enduring jewelry crafted around the world.

Support Makers

From rising and revered artisans, to women-owned brands.

Sparkle, Worry-Free!

100-day returns, and unlimited expert matchmaking sessions.

Shop & Save On Sale

Shop Ready to Ship

Shop New Arrivals